Can a Borrow Pit Be Restored to Native Longleaf Pine–Wiregrass Forest?

November 2, 2026

By Bill Stinson 

Bill Stinson (weewa1430@gmail.com) is a lifelong naturalist and landowner in the Florida Panhandle. Growing up in northwest Florida, he developed an enduring attachment to the region’s longleaf pine–wiregrass forests. Since 2000, he has been restoring that native ecosystem on his 30-acre property learning largely through observation, experimentation, persistence, and occasional help from family and friends. 

Can an abandoned “borrow pit” be restored to something resembling the native ecosystem locally called Longleaf–Wiregrass Forest that preceded it? For the past  two and a half decades, I have been trying to answer that question on my property in rural Gadsden County, in the Florida Panhandle. My starting point was nearly impermeable red clay left behind after soil and sand had been excavated for road construction some 60 years earlier. That soil had been stocked in what in Florida and elsewhere is called a borrow pit, which means an excavated area where dirt, sand, clay, or shell is dug up and removed (“borrowed”) to be used as fill material at another site. 

My starting point was a nearly impermeable layer of red clay exposed when soil and sand were excavated for road construction some 60 years earlier. Such excavation sites are known in Florida and elsewhere as borrow pits, because the materials removed are used for construction or as fill at other locations.

Early failures taught me that planting native species was not enough. Restoring the physical conditions of the soil, controlling aggressive colonizers, and eventually reintroducing fire were equally important. What follows is an account of what worked, what failed, and what a landowner can accomplish through experimentation, persistence, and learning from the land.

Starting with an abandoned borrow pit

In 2000, I built and moved into a house on 12 ha (30 acres) in rural Gadsden County in the West Florida Panhandle. About 60% of the property is mesic or hydric; roughly 5 ha (12 acres) is xeric upland. My eventual goal became restoration of approximately 1.4 ha (3.4 acres) of an old borrow pit within that upland site.

My starting point was nearly impermeable red clay left after soil had been mined for road construction some 60 years earlier. (Another clay is industrially mined in the area: attapulgite. It is grey and used in drilling muds, pet litter, etc. Unlike red clay, attapulgite is relatively scarce on our planet, but found in abundance in northern Gadsden County, Florida and southern Decatur County, Georgia.) 

A cap of sand and much of the material beneath it had been removed, leaving approximately two hectares of bare, flat, nearly impermeable clay. In the deepest portion, roughly 4.6 m (15 ft) of material had disappeared. 

No effort had been made to restore the site.

Could I, a private landowner, with no previous experience in restoration, successfully restore and manage a complex ecosystem on my land? That is the question I have been trying to answer. With occasional help from family and friends, I began small, but restoration gave me too much satisfaction to quit, and the effort kept expanding.

As I said, my goal was to assist in the restoration of the pre-disturbance Longleaf Pine–Wiregrass ecosystem (Pinus palustris, and Aristida stricta) that I had loved as a youngster growing up in northwest Florida. 

An abandoned borrow pit does not behave much like land undergoing ordinary succession. Ours had virtually no remnant of the former forest, little or no useful seed bank, and, in places, essentially no soil. Yet there was sunlight, rain, surrounding forest, and time. What would natural forces do with those resources?

The borrow pit in 2002. The reddish-brown rectangle outlined in yellow is the disturbed area, already heavily colonized by Loblolly pine (Pinus taeda). The nearby highway follows the ridge above the former borrow pit.

What nature brought back—and what it didn’t

When European settlers reached this part of Florida in the early nineteenth century, they encountered extensive upland Longleaf-Wiregrass forests (also sometimes called Longleaf Pine Savanna or Woodland). Wiregrass dominated much of the ground layer, accompanied by an exceptionally diverse herbaceous flora. Frequent fire, often ignited by lightning during the growing season, helped maintain these communities.

Downslope, where greater moisture offered some protection from fire, other species flourished. Among them was loblolly pine, a prolific and fast-growing tree native to the Southeastern USA and a strong colonizer of disturbed land.

Remove frequent fire, however, and the balance changes.

By the time I began working on the borrow pit, loblolly pine had become its undisputed colonizer. After some 60 years of fire suppression, the site supported a loblolly canopy with almost no midstory or ground cover and very little biological diversity. The surrounding forest was primarily oaks, hickories, gums, and other species rather than the historical longleaf–wiregrass community.

Natural forces had indeed revegetated the pit. But they had not recreated the ecosystem that had occupied the uplands before European settlement.

My objective therefore became clearer: help move the borrow pit move toward a younger, self-sustaining version of the historical upland community by reintroducing appropriate local native species, controlling off-site, non-native species and invasive exotics, and restoring fire.

First attempt—and first failure

In late fall 2015, we clear-cut about 0.6 ha (1.5 acres) of loblolly pine. Marketable trees were sold for sawtimber, peeling, and pulp, and the proceeds almost covered the labor costs.

That December we planted 250 longleaf pine seedlings and 250 wiregrass plugs purchased from the Florida Forest Service’s Andrews Nursery in Chiefland. We opened planting holes with a steel dibble bar—a difficult task because the exposed clay was extremely hard.

The first planting of longleaf pine and wiregrass into minimally prepared clay.

Initially, most of the plants appeared to survive. Two years later, however, only about 20% of the Longleaf  saplings and fewer than 5% of the wiregrass plugs remained alive.

The lesson was difficult to miss: planting the right species was not enough if the physical environment could not support them.

The compacted clay was simply inhospitable. 

Learning to rebuild below ground

For our next attempt we tilled the upper 15 cm (6 in) of clay. That improved infiltration somewhat, but beneath the tilled layer the substrate remained brick-hard.

Then Hurricane Michael arrived.

In October 2018, this Category 5 hurricane passed through the region. The surviving young longleaf pines, still in their grass stage and less than 30 cm (12 in) tall, suffered little damage. More than half of the approximately 40-year-old loblollies remaining in the borrow pit were toppled.

In 2018, Hurricane Michael toppled many mature loblolly pines. Their shallow root systems exposed another consequence of the compacted substrate.

The fallen trees revealed something important. Their roots had been unable to penetrate deeply into the compacted clay. Trees were thrown over, leaving pits and tip-up mounds, while rainwater collected on the poorly drained surface.

Our six inches of tillage had not gone nearly deep enough.

We purchased a subsoiler that our compact tractor could pull through the clay. After two or three passes we could fracture the substrate to 50–60 cm (20–24 in).

Deep ripping fractured the compacted clay well below the shallow layer reached by ordinary tillage (November 2020).

The subsoiler often brought up football-sized chunks of clay, which we then pulverized with a 6-foot rotary tiller.

After deep ripping, a rotary tiller broke the large clay fragments into a much more accommodating planting bed (December 2020).

The results changed the project.

Percolation improved and runoff diminished. Roots could penetrate farther. Survival and growth increased dramatically. In later plantings, more than 90% of the longleaf pines survived.

From then on, our basic procedure was simple: rip as deeply as our equipment allowed, then till the fractured clay to create a suitable seed and planting bed.

Rebuilding the plant community

By late 2021 we were ready to expand.

In the decades following the cessation of mining, the site was gradually colonized by an assortment of species not characteristic of the original Longleaf–Wiregrass Forest, including During the decades after the mining operation ended, the site had accumulated an assortment of non-local colonists—loblolly pine (Pinus taeda), sweetgum (Liquidambar styraciflua), maple (Acer floridanum), cherry (Prunus serotina), magnolias               (Magnolia grandiflora, M. pyramidata),  hickory (Carya glabra, C. tomentosa), beech (Fagus grandifolia),  oaks (Quercus laurifolia (laurel oak), Q. stellata (post oak), Q. michauxii (swamp chestnut oak), Q. falcata (southern red oak), Q. nigra (water oak), and  Q, alba (white oak), American holly (Ilex opaca), sparkleberry Vaccinium arboreum), blueberry (Vaccinium elliottii), and wax myrtle (Morella cerifera). Grasses, herbs, as well as several exotic species. We removed many of the woody plants, ripped and tilled the ground, and prepared for another planting. 

A couple of areas of the borrow pit were different. Water remained there for days after heavy rain. Rather than force longleaf into unsuitable conditions, we planted Bald cypress (Taxodium distichum). During wet periods the resulting pools attract frogs, snakes, turtles, and occasionally an egret.

Those areas taught another useful lesson: restoration does not require making every square meter identical. The site’s physical heterogeneity can tell us what belongs where.

The borrow pit after woody vegetation was removed and the compacted substrate deeply ripped. One wetter depression that we left unripped is visible toward the upper right (December 2021).

With grandchildren visiting in early 2022, we planted approximately 200 longleaf seedlings and 200 wiregrass plugs and broadcast a bushel of native wildflower/grass seed mix.

We planted wiregrass plugs in two 3-foot-wide strips across the plot while broadcasting seed elsewhere. This informal experiment allowed us to compare the establishment of plugs and broadcast seed to learn which approach would produce ground cover quickly enough to provide fuel for prescribed fire.

Longleaf seedlings, wiregrass plugs, and seed went into the newly prepared ground, with the help of our grandchildren (March 2022).

Eighteen months later, the answer was encouraging. Wiregrass plugs had produced larger individual plants, but seeded wiregrass was also establishing well. Together with other grasses, there was enough fine fuel to contemplate the next essential step: fire.

Bringing fire back

In March 2024, 27 months after planting, we conducted a prescribed burn.

A light breeze carried a fast-moving fire through the young restoration. Aboveground vegetation burned almost completely to bare ground.

The longleaf and wiregrass survived.

The first prescribed burn swept through the restored ground layer without killing the fire-adapted longleaf pine or wiregrass (March 14, 2024).

Five days later grasses were already resprouting. Green appeared around the protected buds of grass-stage longleaf seedlings. Loblolly seedlings were another matter: most appeared dead, and most were.

A week later the wiregrass had grown several inches and the longleaf seedlings were putting out new green tissue. We could find none that had failed to recover.

Within days of the burn, wiregrass and longleaf were resprouting. Most young loblolly seedlings had been killed.

This was the ecological process we had been working toward. Instead of continually fighting loblolly pine by cutting and pulling seedlings, we finally had enough ground-layer fuel to use one of the processes that historically maintained longleaf pine ecosystems: fire itself.

Three years after planting

By October 2025, the area planted in early 2022 had become recognizably different.

Some longleaf remained in the grass stage, some had entered the characteristic “bottlebrush” stage, and others were already producing lateral branches. Their uneven growth is normal for young longleaf.

More importantly, the once-bare clay now carried a nearly continuous ground layer.

The same area three years after planting and 18 months after prescribed fire. Longleaf growth is uneven, but ground cover is well established (October 2025).
Aerial view showing young longleaf pine developing above an increasingly continuous herbaceous layer (October 2025).

This is not a finished restoration. Perhaps restoration never really is “finished.”

Some of our longleaf were planted too densely and will eventually need thinning. We still need to introduce missing species of forbs and shrubs. Undesirable native species and exotics continue to require control, and prescribed fire must remain part of management if the developing community is to retain its longleaf–wiregrass character.

But the trajectory has changed.

What I learned

For other landowners contemplating restoration on a small scale, my advice is: be brave enough to begin — and prepared to learn.

Our first attempt was not completely naïve, but advice from someone who had done this before might have saved us considerable effort. In retrospect, clear-cutting the loblollies and then dibbling longleaf and wiregrass plugs directly into the hard-as-brick floor of an old borrow pit was not a promising strategy. The greater than 80% failure of the longleaf and more than 95% failure of the wiregrass told us so.

But failure also told us what to investigate next.

We learned that restoring vegetation required first addressing the physical legacy of degradation. Deep ripping and tilling transformed survival. Establishing wiregrass and other fine fuels allowed us to reintroduce prescribed fire. Fire, in turn, began doing some of the ecological work that we previously had been trying to accomplish by hand.

From the time we ripped the clay, in December 2021, and started planting in early 2022, development of the young stand of longleaf visible in October 2025 was less than four years.

What began as an abandoned borrow pit was and is still now becoming a very young version of the ecosystem I remember from my childhood.

There is much more to do. But that, I have discovered, is part of the satisfaction of restoration.

If you have questions or would like more information on this project, you can email the author, Bill Stinson, at weewa1430@gmail.com.


Discover more from Natural History of Ecological Restoration

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Comments

One response to “Can a Borrow Pit Be Restored to Native Longleaf Pine–Wiregrass Forest?”

  1. Aredmondfl Avatar

    Bill, great article! As a former neighbor of this property I am so impressed with what you all accomplished!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *